This study explores how the card game Climate Call and its associated educational materials, can support teaching about climate change and carbon dioxide emissions in upper secondary school as part of environmental and sustainability education (ESE). Using discourse analysis, the study examines the game and materials through three ESE teaching traditions: fact-based, normative, and pluralistic. The findings show that the game incorporates all three, with fact-based and pluralistic traditions being equally prevalent and normative slightly less so. The didactical tetrahedron framework is used to analyse the game’s role in mediating interactions between teachers, students, and content. The game’s versatility allows it to align with different teaching traditions and learning objectives, facilitating discussions, factual knowledge acquisition, and critical thinking. The study underscores the possibilities of educational artefacts such as games to shape learning activities and support ESE teaching. However, it concludes that the possibilities presented by such games are dependent on teachers’ abilities to scaffold learning, relate content to broader sustainability issues, and engage students in critical discussions.