In the context of breastfeeding care, models are lacking that can guide caring practice. This article examines the prerequisites for care to be caring, based on research about breastfeeding difficulties. These prerequisites are presented as a theoretical model of caring that demonstrates that a genuine caring relationship, embodied wisdom, and an ability to create a space for dwelling, together with cultural awareness, form the prerequisites for the breastfeeding story to be a hub in caring practice. The model contributes to the development of caring practices that embrace the existentiality of each woman's breastfeeding experiences.